Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rick Lewis's avatar

I'm grateful you opened this challenge to your readers and, as I mentioned in my summary of my experience, I plan to keep going. I find the same thing with the need for "black and white" guidelines to stay on track, and I've been struggling with where to draw that line with what types of food since there are times when I want to engage with treaty food in family situations. So I decided that the "line" I'm going to experiment with this month is that I won't be eating any treats alone. If I indulge in anything treaty it will be in a shared food situation. I think this will be an interesting stretch and experiment for me.

Expand full comment
Rob Dixon's avatar

An add, and you have taught me this, Jack, is to calorie count using a food scale, each item you consume in a day. As a 58 year old with a lean muscle weight target of 167 lbs, I can, as an active person, consume approximately 2600 calories to maintain that weight. If after dinner I am at 2200 calories, I can likely eat that butter tart indulgently, knowing I am within my caloric target for that day. Is it the healthiest choice? Nope! An every night treat. Nope. A reward? Nah…..but delicious and my weight target remains in place. Having made healthy, calorically smart choices all day, it’s balanced to indulge occasionally. Keeps me on track and doesn’t make food either “good” or “bad”.

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts